A Narratological Reading of Choubak's Tangsir

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Ph. D. Student of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University Shahrekord Branch, Shahrekord, Iran

2 Associate Professor of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University Shahrekord Branch, Shahrekord, Iran

3 Assistant Professor of Arabic Language and Literature, of Persian Language and Literature, Islamic Azad University Shahrekord Branch, Shahrekord, Iran

Abstract

Abstract
One of the frequently-discussed issues in narratology is the analysis of the structure and the plot of the novel which embarks on deconstructing the old texts. Anchored in the ideas of Tudorv and Grimas, this research endeavors to analyze the narratological structure of Tengsir penned by Sadegh Choubak. Tangsir develops linearly on the temporal storyline; therefore, the events occur consecutively in a chain-like fashion for Zayer Mohammad. At the starting point, the situation is depicted to look normal in that Zayer Mohammad is a hardworking man working at Dehkan Harbour. Then, the situation changes with an incident. Karim Hajj Hmzayi borrowed all Zayer Mohammad's properties and refused to return them, pervading a sense of imbalanced situation throughout the novel. All the incidents being unfolded, the narrative ends with a balanced state in the novel. Zayer Mohammad kills Karim and his accomplices and then escapes to Bushehr. According to the pattern of Grimes, Zayer Mohammad is an identifier and the subject of identification involves taking his right from others. In the same vein, Zayer Mohammad is also the receiver and his internal emotion plays the role of a sender. The helpers are portrayed to be Shahro and Asator as well as his feelings. The opposition is comprised of Karim Hajji Hmaze, Sheikh Abu Torab, Mohammad Gonde-Rajab and Aqa Al-Kachal. Regarding data collections, the present study is a descriptive-documentary one conducted using content analysis. Analyzing the elements of narrative design in Tangsir, it can be said that the structure of the novel is in line with the theory of Todorov and Grimas.
1. Introduction
Tangsir develops based on a linear storytime (chained). The events of Zayer Mohammed's personality arise one after another in that, initially, the situation appears to be normal. Subsequently, this equilibrium changes and the imbalanced situation dominates the atmosphere of the novel. Being the events unfolded, the novel's storyline turns to a well-balanced situation, and the fate of the character gets disclosed. Chubak introduces Zayer Mohammed's character to the reader in a mixed manner (direct and indirect descriptions by actions and behavior). This study attempts to analyze the narrative design of Tengsir novel based on structuralist theories such as T. Todorov and A. Grimas.
2. Discussion and analysis
Based on what Tudorff theorizes, the narrative scheme of Tengsir consists of a series of sequences. The storyline in this novel is that the events are consecutively chained to Zayer Mohammed in such a way that the situation is initially depicted as balanced (introduction) within which there are a variety of events. In the aftermath, the construed balanced situation is disturbed by an event (episode 1), and an imbalanced situation dominates the narrative context; Karim Hajzamzah and his allies borrow and invest all his wealth and assets.  At this point, to accomplish his goals, Zayer Mohammad lives various hazardous experiences, including the killing of Karim Haj Hamzah and his allies, as well as coming to grapple with government officials. This creates an upward spiral of events. Describing these incidents comprises the middle of the narrative. Thereafter, with the final incident (chapter 2), the narrative text (story) comes to an end. The story of the novel returns to a well-balanced state of affairs; ending with killing Karim and his allies, Zayer Mohammad escapes from Bushehr with his family.
In what follows, we shall examine the narrative elements in Tangsir based on the theory of Grimes. Identifiers (active, hero): Zayer Muhammad; value-bearing object (the subject of identification): Taking his (own right) property back from Karim and his allies; agent: Zayer Muhammad and the patient: His inner sense; Assistant: Shahro, Asator, His Feelings, the People and ... ; the Anti-agent: Karim Haj Hamzah, Sheikhabotrab, Mohammad Gonderajab and Aqa Ali Kachal and government officials (vice). In the novel, according to the schema mentioned, there are six narrative elements.
3. Conclusion
The narrative process in this novel is shaped in a way that the events are chained one after another for Zayer Mohammad (the main character), in such a way that at first the situation is represented to be balanced (introduction) and this situation involves a variety of events. In this situation, while the agentivity is introduced, a value-bearing object (target) is also identified for the identifier. Furthermore, the character is described in this part of the narrative. Zayer Mohammed (recipient and recogniser) is construed as a hardworking man who sells oat and is regarded as a value-bearing object (money and preservation of honor). In the aftermath, (chapter 1), this balance becomes chaotic an event and an imbalanced situation dominates the narrative environment. Karim and all his allies borrow and spend all Zayer's properties.
At this stage, the activist welcomes various dangers such as killing Karim Hajzamzah and his allies, struggling with government officials to achieve his goals (value-bearing object). This leads to the formation of action and reaction on the part of the patient and anti-agent causing an upward trend in the story-line. Mentioning these events as such constitutes the middle of the narrative and includes the actions and reactions of Zayer Mohammad's personality. At this stage, the identifier is examined and assisted by the assisting forces to overcome the anti-agent forces. At this point, with the final incident happened (chapter 2), the narrative (story) gets to the final phase. Being supported by Shahro, Asator and the people (the supporting forces), he succeeds in regaining his right (his money; identification) from Karim and his allies by shooting them.
The novel's story-line returns to a well-balanced state of affairs and the character finds his fate. After the events narrated, the narrative anchors in a calm shore; he escapes from Bushehr with his family after killing Karim and his allies. In the end, the general (destiny) status is determined in the event of victory or defeat, and the story obtains a new stable state that is the product of the patient and past events interplay. Finally, we can draw the following diagram for the structural analysis of the narrative plot of Tengsir: Initial balance (introducing the agent and Value-bearing object) + disturbance of the equilibrium (episode 1) - introduction: the imbalanced status (examining the patient and his battle with anti-agent and the use of supporting forces) + latest confront of the agent and anti-agent (…..2) - Middle; re-occurrence of the balanced status (the final phase the materialization of the patient's destiny) that a new stable state comes to the surface.

Keywords


References
-  Ahmadi, B.  (1380). Text Structure and Interpretation. 11th ed., Tehran: Markaz.
-  Ahmadi, B. (1373). Modernity and Critical Thinking. 1st ed., Tehran: Markaz.
-  Allende, R. (1999). Love. Jalal Sattari (trans.), Tehran: Toos.
-  Babasalar, A. (2006). Sadegh Chubak and his criticism, Journal of Faculty of Literature and Humanities, University of Tehran, No. 57, pp: 133-151.
-  Bagheri, Kh., Sajadieh, N. & Tavassoli, T. (2011). Research Approaches and Methods in Philosophy of Education. 1st ed., Tehran: Institute for Cultural and Social Studies.
-  Baynaz, F. (2009). An Introduction to Storytelling and Narration. 2nd ed., Tehran: Afraz.
-  Chubak, S. (2005). Tangsir. 1st ed., Tehran: Jamehdaran.
-  Eagleton, T. (2001). An Introduction to Literary Theory. A. Mokhber (trans.), Tehran: Markaz.
-  Forouzandeh, M. (2008). Structural analysis of the story plan of Varaqe and Golshah by Ayyoghi. Journal of the Faculty of Literature and Humanities; 16 (No) 60, 81-65.
-  ـــــــــــــــــــــــ (2012). Narrative structure in the story of Zahak. Exploring Persian Language and Literature; 13 (24), 103-120.
-  Forrester, E. M. (2005). Aspects of the novel. Abraham Younessi (trans.), 5th ed., Tehran: Negah.
-  Iman, M. T. (2009). The paradigmatic foundations of quantitative and qualitative research methods in the humanities. Qom: Hoze and University Research Center.
-  Knight, D. (2009). Creation of the Short Story. Araz Barseghian (trans.), 1st ed., Tehran: Afraz.
-  Marcic, I. (2005). Encyclopedia of Contemporary Literary Theory. M. Mohajer and Mohammad Nabavi (trans.), Tehran: Agah.
-  Mir Abedini, H. (2008). One Hundred Years of Story Writing in Iran. Vols. I and II, 5th ed., Tehran: Chashmeh.
-  Mir Sadeghi, J. (2006). Story Elements. 4th ed., Tehran: Sokhan.
-  Mohadesi Khorasani, Z. (2009). Religious Poetry and the Impact of the Islamic Revolution on It. 1st ed., Tehran: Ashura Cultural Community.
-  Okhovvat, A. (1371). Grammar of the Story. 1st ed., Isfahan: Farda.
-  Sadeghi Fasaei, S. & Erfanmanesh, I. (2015). Methodological Foundations of Documentary Research in the Social Sciences. Journal of Strategy of Culture. (29), 61-91.
-  Sadeghi, I., Aga Khani Bijani, M. & Rezaei, H. (2012). (2012). Structural analysis of Jami's lyrical story, youssef and Zulikha. The bi-quarterly Journal of Lyrical Literature Researches. 10 (19), 123-124.
-  Scholes, R. (2004). An Introduction to Structuralism in Literature. Farzaneh Taheri (trans.), Tehran: Agah.
-  Selden, R. (1999). A Guide to Contemporary Literary Theory. Abbas Mokhbar (trans.), Tehran: Tarh-e Now.
-  Tadieh, J. (1999). Literary Criticism in Twentieth-Century. Mahshid Noohnali (trans.), Tehran: Niloufar.
-  Todorov, T. (2003). Structural Battles. Mohammad Nabavi (trans.), 2nd ed., Tehran: Agah.
-  Tulane, M. J. (2004). A Critical-Linguistic Income on Narrative. Abolfazl Hari (trans.), Tehran: Farabi Cinema Foundation.
-  Watt, I. (2007). The Dawn of the Novel, Theories of the Novel. Hossein Payandeh (trans.), Tehran: Niloufar.
-  Younesi, A. (2009). The Art of Storytelling. 10th ed., Tehran: Negah.